My Car Was Totaled. Now What? A Step-by-Step Guide
- By Car Accident Lawyer Tacoma WA
- actual cash value car accident attorneys near me Car Accident Lawyer Tacoma car injury lawyer near me insurance claim property damage tacoma car accident attorney tacoma car accident lawyer total loss what to do after accident
- With 0 comments
Table of Contents
ToggleMy Car Was Totaled. Now What? A Step-by-Step Guide
After a serious car accident, you get the call from the insurance adjuster. They’ve finished their inspection, and the verdict is in: your car is a “total loss.” This means the insurer has determined it would cost more to repair the vehicle than it was worth before the crash. For most people, this news is followed by a wave of uncertainty. What happens now? How much will they pay me? And how am I supposed to get a new car?
The total loss process can feel like you’re being forced to sell your car on the insurance company’s terms. However, it’s important to know that you have rights in this process, and you do not have to accept the first number they give you.
Navigating this process methodically is the key to ensuring you receive the fair market value for your vehicle, which is crucial for getting you back on the road. This guide breaks down the process into clear, actionable steps.
Useful Information for You: In a Nutshell
- A “Total Loss” is a Financial Decision: It means the cost of repairs plus the salvage value is more than the car’s pre-accident Actual Cash Value (ACV).
- You are Owed the “Actual Cash Value”: The insurance company must pay you what your car was worth in your local Tacoma-area market the moment before the crash.
- Review the Valuation Report Carefully: The insurer must provide you with a detailed report showing the “comparable” vehicles they used to determine your car’s value. Scrutinize this report for inaccuracies.
- You Can (and Should) Negotiate: If you believe their offer is too low, you have the right to negotiate by providing your own evidence of your car’s higher value.
- The Loan Must Be Paid: You are still responsible for paying off any outstanding loan on the vehicle. If the payout is less than the loan balance, you must cover the difference unless you have GAP insurance.
Step 1: Understand the Insurer’s Valuation Report
The insurance company cannot just pull a number out of thin air. They will generate a detailed report, typically from a third-party company like CCC or Mitchell, that determines your car’s Actual Cash Value (ACV). This report is the basis of their offer.
When you receive this report, review it like a detective. Look for:
- The “Comparable” Vehicles: The report will list several vehicles similar to yours that recently sold in your area. Are they truly comparable? Do they have the same trim level, features, and options as your car?
- Condition Adjustments: The adjuster will have rated the condition of your car (e.g., “clean,” “average”). If your car was in excellent, well-maintained condition, make sure the report reflects that. They often lowball this rating.
- Mileage and Options: Ensure the mileage is correct and that all of your car’s features (sunroof, premium sound system, etc.) are listed.
Step 2: Do Your Own Research and Negotiate
If you believe the insurance company’s ACV offer is too low, you have the right to negotiate. You must come prepared with your own evidence.
- Find Your Own “Comps”: Go to online car sales sites (like AutoTrader, Cars.com, etc.) and search for vehicles of the exact same year, make, and model, with similar mileage and options, for sale in the Tacoma/Seattle area. Save screenshots of the asking prices.
- Highlight Your Car’s Best Features: Did you recently put on new tires? Have a detailed service history? Provide receipts and records to the adjuster to argue for a higher valuation.
- Present Your Evidence: Send your evidence to the adjuster with a polite but firm letter explaining why you believe their offer is too low and stating the value you believe is fair based on your research.
Step 3: Handle the Logistics (Loan Payoff and Surrendering the Car)
Once you and the insurer agree on a final ACV, the process moves to the final steps.
- If you have a loan: The insurance company will typically pay your lender directly first. If the ACV is more than your loan balance, you will receive a check for the difference. If it’s less (you’re “upside down”), you are responsible for paying the remaining balance to the lender.
- If you own the car outright: The insurance company will send the full settlement check directly to you.
- Surrendering the Vehicle: You will need to sign the car’s title over to the insurance company. They will then take possession of the vehicle and arrange to have it sold for salvage.
Losing your car in an accident is a major disruption. By understanding the total loss process and advocating for yourself, you can ensure you get the fair value you’re owed. If you are in a dispute with an insurance company over the value of your totaled car in the Tacoma area, search the Car Accident Lawyer Directory Tacoma. An experienced local attorney can take over the negotiation and fight to get you the best possible outcome.
References
- Washington Administrative Code (WAC 284-30-391) – Motor vehicle repair:
The official state regulation that defines “Total Loss” using the formula and outlines the rules insurers must follow when valuing your vehicle.
https://apps.leg.wa.gov/wac/default.aspx?cite=284-30-391
- Washington State Office of the Insurance Commissioner (OIC) – Getting your vehicle repaired:
A consumer guide explaining the total loss process, Actual Cash Value, and your rights when dealing with an insurer for property damage claims.
https://www.insurance.wa.gov/getting-your-vehicle-repaired-after-accident


We hope that through this article, you have a better understanding of your situation after a car accident and feel that you are not alone. The most important part of your recovery is protecting your rights with the right information.
If you need to connect with an expert who will listen to your story and fight on your side, find the best car accident lawyers in Tacoma through a free consultation at the Car Accident Lawyer Directory Tacoma.
Information
Find a Lawyer
Tacoma Car Accident Lawyers
Ask A Lawyer
Google Search Result
Washington State Traffic Accident Information
Washington State Department of Transportation
Washington State Department of Licensing